The PARIS Forums


Home » The PARIS Forums » PARIS: Main » Real drums? Or are these OK?
Real drums? Or are these OK? [message #85811] Sat, 02 June 2007 16:27 Go to next message
Bill L is currently offline  Bill L   UNITED STATES
Messages: 766
Registered: August 2006
Senior Member
I was planning to add real drums to this track, but the tracks I did
with the Groove Agent Demo sound pretty darn good to me. What do you
think? Does it work?

http://www.billlorentzen.com/Geraldine_MP3.mp3

Bill
Re: Real drums? Or are these OK? [message #85813 is a reply to message #85811] Sat, 02 June 2007 17:07 Go to previous messageGo to next message
Graham Duncan is currently offline  Graham Duncan   UNITED STATES
Messages: 147
Registered: December 2008
Senior Member
Bill L wrote:
> I was planning to add real drums to this track, but the tracks I did
> with the Groove Agent Demo sound pretty darn good to me. What do you
> think? Does it work?
>
> http://www.billlorentzen.com/Geraldine_MP3.mp3
>
> Bill

I think real drums would be better -- but they work. Mostly it's the
reverb on the HH and kit that bugs me a bit. Maybe try them drier or
with different reverb/fx?

Graham
Re: Real drums? Or are these OK? [message #85815 is a reply to message #85811] Sat, 02 June 2007 17:56 Go to previous messageGo to next message
Sarah is currently offline  Sarah   UNITED STATES
Messages: 608
Registered: February 2007
Senior Member
Well, the programmed drums are clearly lacking in dynamics, tonal
variations, and other expressive elements a real drummer would add. Also,
the drums seem to be functioning as a glorified metronome rather than really
contributing creatively to the arrangement, which could also be remedied
with a human-powered drumset.

But if it's just a demo . . . well I wouldn't worry about it.

Just my hypercritical opinion based on my personal prejudice in favor of
drummers. (drummers have fast hands)

S


"Bill L" <bill@billlorentzen.com> wrote in message news:4661fea3@linux...
>I was planning to add real drums to this track, but the tracks I did with
>the Groove Agent Demo sound pretty darn good to me. What do you think? Does
>it work?
>
> http://www.billlorentzen.com/Geraldine_MP3.mp3
>
> Bill
Re: Real drums? Or are these OK? [message #85818 is a reply to message #85811] Sat, 02 June 2007 19:56 Go to previous messageGo to next message
Neil is currently offline  Neil
Messages: 1645
Registered: April 2006
Senior Member
It just seem like the wrong kind of kit (or tones) for that
tune... you need something more subtle, whether it's progammed
or not.

Neil


Bill L <bill@billlorentzen.com> wrote:
>I was planning to add real drums to this track, but the tracks I did
>with the Groove Agent Demo sound pretty darn good to me. What do you
>think? Does it work?
>
>http://www.billlorentzen.com/Geraldine_MP3.mp3
>
>Bill
Re: Real drums? Or are these OK? [message #85824 is a reply to message #85811] Sat, 02 June 2007 22:15 Go to previous messageGo to next message
LaMont is currently offline  LaMont
Messages: 828
Registered: October 2005
Senior Member
I like it . The drums work for me. You may want add live cymbals or play cymbal
samples live...Nice work..

Bill L <bill@billlorentzen.com> wrote:
>I was planning to add real drums to this track, but the tracks I did
>with the Groove Agent Demo sound pretty darn good to me. What do you
>think? Does it work?
>
>http://www.billlorentzen.com/Geraldine_MP3.mp3
>
>Bill
Re: Real drums? Or are these OK? [message #85831 is a reply to message #85811] Sat, 02 June 2007 23:37 Go to previous messageGo to next message
excelav is currently offline  excelav   
Messages: 2130
Registered: July 2005
Location: Metro Detroit
Senior Member
As a drummer, I'd say it sounds too programed. The HH is too loud and has
no dynamics.

And yes, I have fast hands; )

Bill L <bill@billlorentzen.com> wrote:
>I was planning to add real drums to this track, but the tracks I did
>with the Groove Agent Demo sound pretty darn good to me. What do you
>think? Does it work?
>
>http://www.billlorentzen.com/Geraldine_MP3.mp3
>
>Bill
Re: Real drums? Or are these OK? [message #85838 is a reply to message #85811] Sun, 03 June 2007 04:58 Go to previous messageGo to next message
John is currently offline  John   UNITED STATES
Messages: 39
Registered: May 2006
Member
I think they sound like shit. The snare sucks, the hihat sucks, the
kick really sucks. Other than than it rocks. Sorry I've got a TD20 and
while those even are not real drums the sound of this drum thingy is
terrible.

Love ya,
John

Bill L wrote:
> I was planning to add real drums to this track, but the tracks I did
> with the Groove Agent Demo sound pretty darn good to me. What do you
> think? Does it work?
>
> http://www.billlorentzen.com/Geraldine_MP3.mp3
>
> Bill
Re: Real drums? Or are these OK? [message #85846 is a reply to message #85811] Sun, 03 June 2007 08:35 Go to previous messageGo to next message
Bill L is currently offline  Bill L   UNITED STATES
Messages: 766
Registered: August 2006
Senior Member
Thanks for the feedback, everyone. The kit can be replaced of course.
This one is very, very "old school" obviously, but the tune is too, so I
thought it kind of fit. I was more concerned about the feel.

I will probably bow to majority opinion in this case and replace them.

Sarah, that's why you're not a Pointer Sister.

Bill


Bill L wrote:
> I was planning to add real drums to this track, but the tracks I did
> with the Groove Agent Demo sound pretty darn good to me. What do you
> think? Does it work?
>
> http://www.billlorentzen.com/Geraldine_MP3.mp3
>
> Bill
Re: Real drums? Or are these OK? [message #85886 is a reply to message #85846] Sun, 03 June 2007 18:06 Go to previous messageGo to next message
Sarah is currently offline  Sarah   UNITED STATES
Messages: 608
Registered: February 2007
Senior Member
Not a Pointer Sister . . . not a Pointer Sister . . . hmm . . . I give up .
.. .

S


"Bill L" <bill@billlorentzen.com> wrote in message news:4662e19d@linux...
> Thanks for the feedback, everyone. The kit can be replaced of course. This
> one is very, very "old school" obviously, but the tune is too, so I
> thought it kind of fit. I was more concerned about the feel.
>
> I will probably bow to majority opinion in this case and replace them.
>
> Sarah, that's why you're not a Pointer Sister.
>
> Bill
>
>
> Bill L wrote:
>> I was planning to add real drums to this track, but the tracks I did with
>> the Groove Agent Demo sound pretty darn good to me. What do you think?
>> Does it work?
>>
>> http://www.billlorentzen.com/Geraldine_MP3.mp3
>>
>> Bill
Re: Real drums? Or are these OK? [message #85903 is a reply to message #85886] Sun, 03 June 2007 21:07 Go to previous messageGo to next message
brandon[2] is currently offline  brandon[2]
Messages: 380
Registered: June 2006
Senior Member
Drums are definitely holding this mix back.
Hat, and cymbals the most.
Snare rolls bother me.
Drums to upfront altogether for my taste.
Love the guitar..needs to be more upfront for my taste.
Is the bass guitar a VSTi?
Real drums will totally bring this mix alive IMO.





"Sarah" <sarahjane@sarahtonin.com> wrote:
>Not a Pointer Sister . . . not a Pointer Sister . . . hmm . . . I give up
.
>. .
>
>S
>
>
>"Bill L" <bill@billlorentzen.com> wrote in message news:4662e19d@linux...
>> Thanks for the feedback, everyone. The kit can be replaced of course.
This
>> one is very, very "old school" obviously, but the tune is too, so I
>> thought it kind of fit. I was more concerned about the feel.
>>
>> I will probably bow to majority opinion in this case and replace them.
>>
>> Sarah, that's why you're not a Pointer Sister.
>>
>> Bill
>>
>>
>> Bill L wrote:
>>> I was planning to add real drums to this track, but the tracks I did
with
>>> the Groove Agent Demo sound pretty darn good to me. What do you think?

>>> Does it work?
>>>
>>> http://www.billlorentzen.com/Geraldine_MP3.mp3
>>>
>>> Bill
>
>
Re: Real drums? Or are these OK? [message #86139 is a reply to message #85903] Tue, 05 June 2007 20:01 Go to previous messageGo to next message
Bill L is currently offline  Bill L   UNITED STATES
Messages: 766
Registered: August 2006
Senior Member
Yeah, bass is fake too. I could play the bass, but it's such a labor for
me. I'm lazy.

Thanks for the input.

Brandon wrote:
> Drums are definitely holding this mix back.
> Hat, and cymbals the most.
> Snare rolls bother me.
> Drums to upfront altogether for my taste.
> Love the guitar..needs to be more upfront for my taste.
> Is the bass guitar a VSTi?
> Real drums will totally bring this mix alive IMO.
>
>
>
>
>
> "Sarah" <sarahjane@sarahtonin.com> wrote:
>> Not a Pointer Sister . . . not a Pointer Sister . . . hmm . . . I give up
> .
>> . .
>>
>> S
>>
>>
>> "Bill L" <bill@billlorentzen.com> wrote in message news:4662e19d@linux...
>>> Thanks for the feedback, everyone. The kit can be replaced of course.
> This
>>> one is very, very "old school" obviously, but the tune is too, so I
>>> thought it kind of fit. I was more concerned about the feel.
>>>
>>> I will probably bow to majority opinion in this case and replace them.
>>>
>>> Sarah, that's why you're not a Pointer Sister.
>>>
>>> Bill
>>>
>>>
>>> Bill L wrote:
>>>> I was planning to add real drums to this track, but the tracks I did
> with
>>>> the Groove Agent Demo sound pretty darn good to me. What do you think?
>
>>>> Does it work?
>>>>
>>>> http://www.billlorentzen.com/Geraldine_MP3.mp3
>>>>
>>>> Bill
>>
>
Re: Real drums? Or are these OK? [message #86157 is a reply to message #85811] Tue, 05 June 2007 22:07 Go to previous messageGo to next message
TCB is currently offline  TCB
Messages: 1261
Registered: July 2007
Senior Member
Hey Bill,

Are you the guitar player? You have a few Robben Ford CDs in the car CD changer
don't you? Very nice playing, has that very vocal, vowel sounding tone that
good distorted blues/jazz/rock guitar sounds do.

I've used Groove Agent on occasion but think it's almost always best replaced
by a real drummer even if he's only using triggers for the cymbals. You'll
get much more dynamics even if the drummer is trying to play like a robot.


Still, very nice work. I was close to having those kind of chops at one point
in my life but I sure as hell don't anymore.

TCB

Bill L <bill@billlorentzen.com> wrote:
>I was planning to add real drums to this track, but the tracks I did
>with the Groove Agent Demo sound pretty darn good to me. What do you
>think? Does it work?
>
>http://www.billlorentzen.com/Geraldine_MP3.mp3
>
>Bill
Re: Real drums? Or are these OK? [message #86240 is a reply to message #86157] Wed, 06 June 2007 19:55 Go to previous message
Bill L is currently offline  Bill L   UNITED STATES
Messages: 766
Registered: August 2006
Senior Member
Thanks, Thad, it's me. I does love me some Robben Ford. ;-) He's about
the best blues player out there for my money. Prolly 'cause he's a lot
more than a blues player.

I don't usually write stuff like that, but I just dug the first 3
changes and had to write something after them. Usually I play Latin and
jazz, although I do have a long, sordid rock and R & B past life too.

I think I did get a pretty nice tone. You're going to laugh - it's a
custom Strat type w/ EMGs into either a Pod (mark 1) or a Vox Tonelab.
With a UAD1 Pultec and 1176. That's about as digitalectric as you can
get, but dang it sounds warm enough doesn't it?

When do I get to hear some of your new album, or old albums?

Bill


TCB wrote:
> Hey Bill,
>
> Are you the guitar player? You have a few Robben Ford CDs in the car CD changer
> don't you? Very nice playing, has that very vocal, vowel sounding tone that
> good distorted blues/jazz/rock guitar sounds do.
>
> I've used Groove Agent on occasion but think it's almost always best replaced
> by a real drummer even if he's only using triggers for the cymbals. You'll
> get much more dynamics even if the drummer is trying to play like a robot.
>
>
> Still, very nice work. I was close to having those kind of chops at one point
> in my life but I sure as hell don't anymore.
>
> TCB
>
> Bill L <bill@billlorentzen.com> wrote:
>> I was planning to add real drums to this track, but the tracks I did
>> with the Groove Agent Demo sound pretty darn good to me. What do you
>> think? Does it work?
>>
>> http://www.billlorentzen.com/Geraldine_MP3.mp3
>>
>> Bill
>
Previous Topic: Politics ! That's what's important !
Next Topic: OT: An Old Hot Dog Can Teach Us Some New Tricks
Goto Forum:
  


Current Time: Tue Nov 26 09:19:10 PST 2024

Total time taken to generate the page: 0.05728 seconds