The PARIS Forums: PARIS: Main » Am I deaf or what?

Home » The PARIS Forums » PARIS: Main » Am I deaf or what?

Show: Today's Messages :: Polls :: Message Navigator

Am I deaf or what? [message #105195]

Thu, 15 April 2010 08:35

dnafe

Messages: 390
Registered: February 2009

Senior Member

There is an ongoing debate at GearSlutz about the quality of soundblaster cards vs...

Three stereo audio wav files were presented and people are chiming in as to which is which.

My problem is I ran them through paris and I can't really hear a difference...there are subtle differences but not consistent enough for me to say one way or the other which is which

Could someone go to the thread and grab the full mix files, load them into paris and tell me if they can hear a difference.

http://www.gearslutz.com/board/gear-shoot-outs-sound-file-co mparisons-audio-tests/483563-sound-blaster-files-can-you-hea r-difference.html

Thanks

Report message to a moderator

Re: Am I deaf or what? [message #105196 is a reply to message #105195]

Thu, 15 April 2010 09:50

drfrankencopter

Messages: 137
Registered: July 2009

Senior Member

Didn't listen in Paris, but at work thru a Dell and AT headphones. I listened to about 30 seconds of each tune.

Initial impressions: I thought A sounded a little smeared/distorted in the high end (hi-hat in particular), while B & C were close.

Cheers

Kris

Report message to a moderator

Re: Am I deaf or what? [message #105197 is a reply to message #105196]

Thu, 15 April 2010 09:59

kerryg

Messages: 1529
Registered: February 2009

Senior Member
Administrator

Haven't got time to listen at the moment, but that won't stop me making a confident prediction - the winner will always be the one that's better written, better arranged and better played.

Very Happy

"... being bitter is like swallowing poison and waiting for the other guy to die..." - anon

[Updated on: Thu, 15 April 2010 10:00]

Report message to a moderator

Re: Am I deaf or what? [message #105198 is a reply to message #105197]

Fri, 16 April 2010 01:42

rick

Messages: 1976
Registered: February 2006

Senior Member

don,
could you please define what "what" is so the winner of the 2 choices can be declared.

thank you
rick

Report message to a moderator

Re: Am I deaf or what? [message #105199 is a reply to message #105198]

Fri, 16 April 2010 04:02

dnafe

Messages: 390
Registered: February 2009

Senior Member

The question posed was "is there a noticeable difference" between the three files generated by these three cards

Soundblaster
Delta 1010
Lynx Aurora

Some guys are hearing huge differences, some like me were hearing very little difference.

I will qualify my statement by saying I was at a very loud Nickelback concert on Sunday and my ears stop ringing only yesterday so that might have had something to do with my results because I tried again and was able to pick out all three files consistently as A / B or C.

Couldn't say which file was generated by which card as I am unfamiliar with all of them. As for the results...it seems that B is the overwhelming choice as the original source file

[Updated on: Fri, 16 April 2010 04:04]

Report message to a moderator

Re: Am I deaf or what? [message #105201 is a reply to message #105199]

Fri, 16 April 2010 13:35

Ted Gerber

Messages: 705
Registered: January 2009

Senior Member

Yeah, lots of angst over there...

I really wonder though, if the most important conversion is the AD off the top.
All three files began as a performance captured through the Lynx. Therefore, clocking in particular is uniformly stellar.

Applying the old "whatever is upstream counts the most" reasoning, I really think that if these had been tracked through each of the same three cards at source, there would be much more significant difference.

As it is, all three get to work with a very good source. The DA is only half (maybe even less than half) of the equation IMO.

Ted

Report message to a moderator

Re: Am I deaf or what? [message #105203 is a reply to message #105201]

Fri, 16 April 2010 14:13

dnafe

Messages: 390
Registered: February 2009

Senior Member

Actually the test that was proposed was analogue tape (2 track) as source / Soundblaster / Lavry Gold or something similar run through a pair of high end monitors

Determine which file is which

Two studios were picked out, one in LA (where Mixerman lives) the other in NYC (where Ethan lives) Time and date to be determined and my understanding is Ethan backed out.

Then this test popped out of nowhere.

For the record my hearing is almost back to normal and I can hear differences in both the old set of files and the new set of files

[Updated on: Fri, 16 April 2010 14:16]

Report message to a moderator

Re: Am I deaf or what? [message #105206 is a reply to message #105203]

Sat, 17 April 2010 02:45

rick

Messages: 1976
Registered: February 2006

Senior Member

don,

my question was a tongue in cheek way to ask what the "what" in on the "am i deaf or what".

i may be 60, but i can still tell time...and most times without help.

now i've got to get back to the banjo minnow infomercial to see how it ends.

Report message to a moderator

Previous Topic:	Are there advantages to Running XP?
Next Topic:	issues with headphone mix setup

Goto Forum:

-=] Back to Top [=-

[ Syndicate this forum (XML) ] [

] [

]

Current Time: Thu Dec 26 23:35:00 PST 2024

Total time taken to generate the page: 0.01586 seconds